Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Prayers for members Harvey and Al Weidman.
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
Pages: 1, 2
ConeDodger
The dam itself is apparently holding, but the Emergency Spillway which is being used for the first time in the 50 year history of the dam is eroding away quickly and expected to fail. Oroville is below the dam.

Residents have been told to evacuate. sad.gif
Porschef
Showing this on the weather channel, hope all who need to evacuate are safe.
sad.gif
Cracker
Yeah, devastating! I've been following that - amazing failure - hope everyone evacuates safely!

T
SirAndy
We went there in September for our last camping trip of the year and stayed at the campground right at the top of the dam.
The water was so low that they had to extend the boat ramp some 300 feet down and were advising people against hiking down to the water.
You could not have thrown a rock from the top of the boat ramp and hit the water.
It was totally surreal, actually.


And now the whole thing is overflowing ...
blink.gif
914_teener
Yes...as a civil engineer this is astounding. Not often that you see something like this.

Apparently the dam is holding, however with damage to the main spillway and and using the emergency spillway only....there is no control over the amount of water overtopping the spillway.....meaning the area downstream is subject to that flow.

They can't use the mail spillway any more as it may erode the division to the main dam.

This is a bad situation and my prayers are for the people downstream. Let' pray for it to stop raining...never thought I'd say that after the last six years.
914_teener
Apparently there is so much water overtopping the emergency spillway it is in danger of structurally failing by undermining it.

This is a bad situation.
Rand
For those who haven't seen it, this video gives you an idea of what things were looking like today:

https://www.facebook.com/abc7news/videos/10155133010292079/
walterolin
KCRA has a live feed with chopper video.

The scary thing is the amount of mud in the water from what I think is the emergency spillway.
Cairo94507
OMG! That is just horrific. I hope everyone is able to get out and be safe. How does our infrastructure get to this point in CA? Aside from all of the residents, I particularly hope Harvey and Al do OK in this. sad.gif
RickS
Shocking situation. Can only hope the dam integrity survives. My thoughts are with those having to evacuate. Keep safe.
KELTY360
QUOTE(Cairo94507 @ Feb 12 2017, 07:33 PM) *

How does our infrastructure get to this point in CA?


Howard Jarvis

Watching this closely and hoping for the best.
Blue6
Kelty, really, blaming Howard Jarvis? Weed must be legal where you live. Remember, "moderation".

On to the facts. My niece evacuated from her home in Oroville yesterday. Thank god because the area is complete gridlock today. She went to stay with my inlaws in Yuba City which is now under voluntary evacuation. Apparently everything along the Feather River is in danger.
Larmo63
We needed high speed rail more than water management in California, apparently.
Mikey914
Pretty spectacular
matthepcat
One of my employees is in the Army National Guard. He was activated tonight to support disaster response in the Lake Oroville area.
rhodyguy
I had not previously seen the image mark posted. The size of the resevior is incredible. I hope the dam holds and the weather pattern breaks.
Cracker
Hitting close to home here too...my cousin's family of six lives in Gridley - just south of Oroville - they have evacuated to my aunt/uncles in Grass Valley. It took several hours to make a trip that usually would take 35 minutes. Hoping for the best!

T

QUOTE(Blue6 @ Feb 13 2017, 01:10 AM) *

Kelty, really, blaming Howard Jarvis? Weed must be legal where you live. Remember, "moderation".

On to the facts. My niece evacuated from her home in Oroville yesterday. Thank god because the area is complete gridlock today. She went to stay with my inlaws in Yuba City which is now under voluntary evacuation. Apparently everything along the Feather River is in danger.

Shadowfax
Grateful that the evacuation order was given. Hopeful that tragedy is averted. Praying for my Cali peeps.
If they should need anything, can someone local help organize a way to raise funds or get needed supplies their way?
AlanB
Great thought. If help is needed, please post what we can do. I only know Harvey, and he's one of the special folk.





Mueller
One of my fellow Volvo buddies lives up there and has been trying to pack his stuff up for a while now.

napasteve
"We needed high speed rail more than water management in California, apparently."

Larmo, this is exactly what I was thinking.
eeyore
QUOTE(napasteve @ Feb 13 2017, 11:19 AM) *

"We needed high speed rail more than water management in California, apparently."

Larmo, this is exactly what I was thinking.


How else are you going to escape a 30 foot wall of water?
napasteve
We need to stop calling it "High Speed Rail". It's really the Graft Express.
JmuRiz
QUOTE(rhodyguy @ Feb 13 2017, 04:35 AM) *

...I hope the dam holds and the weather pattern breaks.

I think I saw they are supposed to get more rain this week.

At least it doesn't look like a Johnstown situation, and hopefully never turns into one!
ConeDodger
Heard from Al on Facebook. He's OK. He's 26 miles up the mountain above Oroville so he's safe. He didn't respond yet about Harvey.

horizontally-opposed
Sounds like Harvey and his wife are ok also, with their house on high ground.
Cairo94507
I hope their shop is OK too.
7TPorsh
I can never understand why people settle and develop towns under such a situation.
Like all the villages at the base of volcanoes in S. America. Seat of the pants living I guess....
Mikey914
Well this is the 1st time that spillway has been used. The expectations were it would function as planned. As CA has has a water shortage for so long who would conceive of a massive surplus? What you can't see from my picture is the massive volume of water behind the Dam. If this were to suddenly give way this could have reprocussion all the way down to the bay.
JustinMeier
QUOTE(Larmo63 @ Feb 12 2017, 11:16 PM) *

We needed high speed rail more than water management in California, apparently.


This is why I'm happy to be in AZ now.. Jerry Brown and the CA Legislature are out of control.

Stay safe all, hopefully they will be able to pull the level down 50ft like they want to.
horizontally-opposed
QUOTE(Cairo94507 @ Feb 14 2017, 06:02 AM) *

I hope their shop is OK too.


I think the shop is at their home now. At least, I remember something to that effect. But, yes, I hope so too!

QUOTE(7TPorsh @ Feb 14 2017, 09:52 AM) *

I can never understand why people settle and develop towns under such a situation.
Like all the villages at the base of volcanoes in S. America. Seat of the pants living I guess....


Someone can correct me if I am wrong, but I think Oroville was there long before the dam above it. The downtown sure looks a lot older than 1968, and Wikipedia indicates it was Ophir City until the first post office opened in 1854. Incorporated in 1906.

People have been settling in stupid places (around the world) for ages. California is no different, but maybe worse given its drought or deluge...and that other phenomenon that comes along "occasionally." Reisner's "California: A Dangerous Place" is well worth the read, whether you live here or not http://www.salon.com/2003/03/05/reisner/ I guess a lot of folks are willing to take some risk in exchange for this state's natural beauty, weather, diversity, and culture. Even so, there are some parts of it I would not want to live in. The risk is just too high.

The thing I never get is when people in other parts of the union express little concern or worse for CA—they seem to forget that CA (and its water system) are critical parts of our nation's food supply, and that CA contributes a tremendous amount of money to the federal government. We're all in this together...and I sure hope those involved can keep that dam together. What a wild pity that it wasn't fixed when the lake was nearly empty.
914_teener
QUOTE(JustinMeier @ Feb 14 2017, 10:03 AM) *

QUOTE(Larmo63 @ Feb 12 2017, 11:16 PM) *

We needed high speed rail more than water management in California, apparently.


This is why I'm happy to be in AZ now.. Jerry Brown and the CA Legislature are out of control.

Stay safe all, hopefully they will be able to pull the level down 50ft like they want to.



This has nothing to do with politics.

You wouldn.t be living in Arizona if not for the government sponsered projects like Boulder Dam.

We live in a complicated environment dependent on each other at certain times.

The post was a call for prayer not for a political analysis.

Please keep that to yourself.
ConeDodger
QUOTE(horizontally-opposed @ Feb 14 2017, 03:13 PM) *

QUOTE(Cairo94507 @ Feb 14 2017, 06:02 AM) *

I hope their shop is OK too.


I think the shop is at their home now. At least, I remember something to that effect. But, yes, I hope so too!


Probably. Last time I was there he said something about a new property owner wanting to double the lease... glad they're ok...
Mikey914
If you look st the picture I posted Sunday vs what's up today on the news. You will notice it's not overflowing outside the spillway anymore. You can see it (where the water was). Clearly. That's what concerned me most.
EdwardBlume
What concerns me the most are more storms and massive snow melt. sad.gif
SirAndy
QUOTE(RobW @ Feb 14 2017, 01:10 PM) *
What concerns me the most are more storms and massive snow melt. sad.gif

Supposed to dump a lot more rain and snow melt this weekend ...
sad.gif
SirAndy
QUOTE(Mikey914 @ Feb 14 2017, 11:09 AM) *
If you look st the picture I posted Sunday vs what's up today on the news. You will notice it's not overflowing outside the spillway anymore. You can see it (where the water was). Clearly. That's what concerned me most.

When we were camping there in September (you can actually see the campground in your pic) you would not have been able to see those boats in your picture.
The water level was so low (a good 300 feet down) that the boats would not have shown from that angle.
unsure.gif
horizontally-opposed
QUOTE(Mikey914 @ Feb 14 2017, 11:09 AM) *

If you look st the picture I posted Sunday vs what's up today on the news. You will notice it's not overflowing outside the spillway anymore. You can see it (where the water was). Clearly. That's what concerned me most.


In a way, your pic is better than any I have seen—in that it really shows how tiny that (massive) primary spillway is in the context of that lake.

If the lake above it is a bathtub, the main spillway is a straw, and not one from McDonalds but more like one side of those cheap, tiny "double" straws used in every office building and church of the 1980s.

Yes re: more rain and more snowmelt. This isn't good.
Mikey914
I carry a cheap digital camera with me for just this occasion. The zoom isn't great but I do get to see some interesting things.

Just a matter of time. Hopefully there is enough of it to drain down to a safe level. The SMF valley looks like it's maxed out only one levy the broke on the west side, but it had a second behind it so only a few fields and a minimal number of houses affected. The levels will not be receding soon.
Nogoodwithusernames
Me and my parents evacuated Sunday night but are in Yuba City so were able to come back the next day, can't imagine living closer and having to be gone until this clears up. We loaded up the truck and took that and my 914 on a 3 hour drive that usually takes about 25 minutes. Gotta say that was not fun with a manual transmission!

From what I know they are doing some temporary repairs to be able to keep draining water. (Giant scale sandbags basically) And they are (yesterday at least, haven't checked in today) dumping about 100,000 cubic feet of water per second down the main spillway to lower the water levels before this next storm. Hopefully it holds up well enough, the damage to it is a couple thousand feet from the dam apparently.

The cause for emergency evac was the auxiliary spillway (furthest left in that photo) as the erosion from it got really close to that concrete skirt. As far as I know the dam itself was in no danger.
ConeDodger
Heard from Harvey this AM. His house is at 180', his shop at 87'. They evacuated to their cabin which is much higher as the recommended evacuation was 200' and lower. He's back but has been told to be evacuation alert.

So, all is well as of now. cheer.gif
Spoke
Good luck guys; hope all stays safe.

That dam looks mighty scary being as high and full as it is. Plus it's an earthen dam?

Question:

What is the purpose of this dam? Flood control? Water supply? Power?
Cracker
Water supply and power for sure...possibly flood control too.

T

QUOTE(Spoke @ Feb 15 2017, 04:08 PM) *

What is the purpose of this dam? Flood control? Water supply? Power?

AZBanks
Praying we don't have a repeat of the Teton dam disaster.

http://www.history.com/topics/us-states/id...sters-teton-dam
GregAmy
QUOTE(Spoke @ Feb 15 2017, 04:08 PM) *
What is the purpose of this dam? Flood control? Water supply? Power?

All of the above.

Note that the 770' dam itself is not at risk; it's fine.

Haven't read the entire thread, but Saturday/Sunday's issue was a culmination of a couple of things. First, earlier failure of the downstream primary spillway (the long concrete chute) which caused them to reduce the flow through that spillway to avoid further damage. They intentionally allowed the reservoir level to rise and overtop the emergency weir for that purpose.

What they had not accounted for was the erosion below that weir. As water volume increased over the weir that area became significantly eroded and scouring below it started to walk up toward the weir. They called for immediate evacuation because they saw the scouring moving toward the weir and were concerned they could not stop the flow over it before it compromised and they lost the weir. To address that they doubled the flow through the primary spillway (that was a ballsy call) and coupled to the coincidental (and fortunate) significantly reduced flow INTO the reservoir, they stopped the flow over the weir, alleviating that immediate problem.

They are now armoring that weir overflow area with stone bags and grouting so that if the level does rise above the weir again that area will be secure. Fortunately, the primary spillway damage is stabilized at the current flow of 100k, so there's no immediate risk there either. They'll continue to run the spillway at that "known safe" flow of 100k to draw down the reservoir as much as possible as a buffer against future inflows.

So again: no danger to the primary dam, situation stabilized at the spillways, with mitigation efforts ongoing to ensure it doesn't happen again. Here's a nice link to see current flows in and out, as well as reservoir level; for reference, flow begins over the weir at 901 feet. Hit "latest" at the bottom to get updates:

http://cdec.water.ca.gov/cgi-progs/queryF?...mp;span=24hours

Not associated with the program in any way. Have some Internet-friends that are, but this info is all publicly available.
Rand
The dam is absolutely at risk if the erosion gets bad enough! That's the whole reason for the concern. Thankfully, it looks like that's not going to be an issue now that they've been able to get the water level down and stop the erosion. BUT, there's more rain in the forecast, so we can't assume everything is just going to be ok.
GregAmy
QUOTE(Rand @ Feb 15 2017, 05:55 PM) *

The dam is absolutely at risk if the erosion gets bad enough!

No, that's entirely wrong. The main 770' dam is not at risk in any way. In fact, if the erosion below the weir were to have continued up and completely taken it out , that would have, in fact, REDUCED the risk to the dam (that's what spillways are for). And even if the almost-entirely-impossible were to happen and both the weir and the primary spillway were completely taken out, there's no reasonable possibility that the erosion damage would migrate around that corner to the point where flows would erode the earthen dam. The most likely scenario in that case would be those spillway structures would collapse and take out that entire hillside below them down to bedrock all the way to the river (they were not even close to that scenario).

Now, if you're using the word "dam" to refer to the entire SYSTEM, then yes, each of those components is part of that "dam system". But, I'm using the word "dam" to refer to the 770' high primary structure that blocks off the main channel of the Feather River. And that structure was not, and is not, in any danger of foreseeable compromise in any way.

That's a fact, and not an alternative one. Yes, I am an engineer.

I think we'll find that this whole thing was a result of lack of imagination. When they designed this system in the 60s, they pretty much over-designed the primary spillway's capability to handle the water flows into that valley. As such they did not put as much emphasis on designing a stronger weir (which was intended only to take care of flows that the primary spillway could not.)

What I think they failed to imagine was a compromise to the primary spillway. "But for" that compromise, this would have been a non-event (combined flows have been less than what that system handled easily in the 1997 floods). That thought is supported by the last-minute scrambling to clear the hillside of potentially-clogging vegetation, grouting and rip rap below the toe of the weir and along the roadside, and surprise at the levels of erosion below the weir.

Mother Nature has little empathy for the hubris oversight of Man.
Rand
The experts I heard talking were saying if the erosion got deep enough it would undermine the dam itself. If that happened it would lead to failure of the actual dam.

But hey, I have no interest in arguing it. I was just sharing info. You clearly know more than I do on the subject. beerchug.gif
GregAmy
The erosion of concern last weekend was for that area below the emergency weir, not the main 770' dam.

CA DWR has been doing an excellent job of providing up to date photos of weir damage repair:

http://pixel-ca-dwr.photoshelter.com/galle...Spillway-Damage

In the link below (not allowed to insert photo here), the area that caused the concern is the dark grey grouted area in the foreground. Look in that second "before" photo, and you can see how that was working its way up toward the weir (it's the area to the far lower left in the photo). Had that erosion made it all the way there it could have compromised and collapsed the weir. If that end of the weir let go, it may have taken the whole thing with it, and potentially continued across to take out the primary spillway. And that would have been "really bad".

They were backed into an ugly corner that evening: allow the reservoir level to increase and risk losing the weir, or increase the flows through the primary spillway to reduce the reservoir level, and risk further damage to the spillway. Someone made the (in hindsight, clearly correct) gutsy call for the second option, and the primary spillway handled the extra load just fine, allowing the reservoir level to drop below 901 (and continuing as we type).

Today:
http://pixel-ca-dwr.photoshelter.com/galle...-02-15-2017-jpg

Before:
IPB Image
914_teener
Should the wier structure have failed completly all the lake water up to the main dam level level would have been drained uncontrolably into the valley. It would be pure conjecture to speculate how it would fail....eithier a point failure or all at once. I think the elevation differential is about 9 feet. Everyone at my work was talking about this today.

They did the right thing in all cases by risking further damage to the main spillway and evacuating those in danger.


As God would have it......the storms held off a week.

My prayers are still with them until the damage is repaired and we are into the dry season.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.